"The Old Man and the Sea" and "Tuesdays with Morrie" both explain the courage to speak out about life and death. Although the Settings and characters of the two works are different, they both convey the importance of dignity and love. The main similarity is that they both show how the protagonist comes to terms with death in his brave own way. Santiago, the old man in Hemingway's novel, doesn't give up his dream of catching marlins. Morrie has also come to terms with his terminal illness, but he has not been defeated by it. He accepts that he is going to die and openly expresses his feelings, especially to his student Mickey. He also retains his sense of humor and curiosity and continues to teach others his perspective on life. The main difference between the two works is that they have very different views on the role of nature in human life and death.
In The Old Man and the Sea, Santiago knows his life is coming to an end, but he still holds on to his dream of one day catching a big fish. He showed perseverance and resilience in the face of adversity and, as he said, "a man can be destroyed, but not defeated". This statement demonstrates Santiago's unwavering belief in his own strength and his determination to refuse to be defeated by circumstances, reflecting traditional masculinity that emphasizes physical endurance and determination.
On the other hand, in Tuesday with Morrie, the character is facing his own terminal illness, but he chooses not to let it bring him down. He embraces his emotions and openly expresses his feelings in a way that defies traditional notions of masculinity. Morrie's commitment to living life to the fullest is evident in his words: "I embrace aging. It's very simple. As you grow, you learn more... It's growing." The words underlined Murray's optimistic outlook on life and his determination to continue learning and growing, even in the face of his illness. Murray's depiction presents a more emotionally expressive, dynamic sense of masculinity that is completely different from Hemingway's novels.
In addition, the two works have different views on the role of nature in human life. In The Old Man and the Sea, Santiago sees nature as a cruel force that challenges him. As he tries to bring the Marlins back to shore, he faces storms, sharks, and hunger. Nature is portrayed as a formidable opponent, testing Santiago's strength and resilience. Morrie, by contrast, found comfort and joy in nature with Morrie on Tuesday. He appreciates birds, flowers, clouds, and the changing seasons, considers nature a source of serenity and inspiration, treats those around him more gently, and does not waste time accomplishing things he regrets and that are meaningful. Mitch is his way of doing it. Morrie's views reflect a deeper connection to the natural world.
Together, "The Old Man and the Sea" and "Tuesdays with Morrie" show different masculinity and offer very different perspectives on the role of nature in human life. Santiago embodies a traditional, macho character who is relentless in achieving his goals. Morrie on the other hand, challenges societal expectations by embracing vulnerability and emotional expression. The different views of nature in the two works further highlight the diversity of human perspectives in describing male characters.
Either way, both stories teach readers valuable lessons about life and death, emphasizing the importance of courage and love in the face of adversity.
网友评论